Misty rice terraces at first light, with a line-drawn figure climbing them
The duality of duality

Everything you do has a light and a dark side, and an opposite. And the opposite, too, has a light and a dark side.

What looks kind also has a dark side, and what looks selfish also has a light side. The Shadow Map lays this out in five positions.

The five positions

Choose an example, then a position.

Example

+The Conscious Thesis

Kindness

Like any map, it is not the territory. The words on it are not prescriptive or definitive. They are there to aid thought, and deeper engagement with what they represent.

enantiodromia

“Running to the opposite”

The tendency of things at their extremes to become their opposites. It was coined by the Greek philosopher Heraclitus and revived many times by Jung, who wrote that "every psychological extreme secretly contains its own opposite".

If all you care about is being seen as kind, it will not be long before the shadow rears its head.

Reconciling the two

Synthesis

Reconciling the two is not mere compromise, not balance, not meeting somewhere in the middle — it gives way to a third thing, which contains the underlying truth of both sides, discards the falsity of both, and creates something entirely new that didn't exist before.

Read more

Hegel's term for this was Aufhebung, usually translated as sublation, which means something close to transcending and including at once. The synthesis is a higher-order version of the thesis: one that does not violate its opposite, and exists in healthy relationship to it, enabling it to carry out its true thesis all the better.

It comes from the tension of opposites. Understanding the map helps, but the tension still has to be borne for the contradiction to be reconciled, and this is where most of the work is done. As Jung described in his essay on the transcendent function, it is from this tension that development occurs.

Shadow Dialectics

Quality, quantity and direction

Many of the confusions around shadow and shadow work arise from the conflation of three different dimensions.

Quality

What it is

The specific preference, trait or behaviour.

Quantity

How much

The magnitude with which it is expressed.

Direction

In service of what

The intention with which it is applied.

Quality
Efficiency and ruthlessness share a quality.
Quantity
In one sense, ruthlessness is efficiency taken to its extreme.
Direction
It also differs in direction: the energy is used only in the service of itself, and leaves its opposite out almost entirely.
Read more

Much of the popular thinking on shadow runs the three together: it portrays certain traits as good or evil in themselves; it mistakes a difference in magnitude for a difference in quality; and it treats abuse of power as a trait in itself.

In truth, any trait can be used in the service of power and the violation of freedom, not only those that you, anyone else or society at large tends to judge as bad.

When two people can't get on, it is often put down to a clash of types: one a thinker, say, and the other a feeler. It is rarely that simple, because direction is entirely a moral matter, irrespective of type, quality or even surface values. Any two people who take responsibility and cultivate empathy can find a way to get on, and any two who don't will inevitably fall out.

Power and shadow

Often what people call shadow is really power, or an abuse of it.

The desire to force and maintain a current thesis on the world, and on oneself. There is nothing evil about power in itself, but one-sidedness must find ways to justify itself on its own terms. Ultimately, it is born of a desire to avoid aspects of oneself and of reality.

Using the map

Three places to start

On yourself

Any thesis you identify with can be mapped. Personality Dynamics applies the map to the eight cognitive functions Carl Jung described, each with a character name in the Make it Conscious Method™.

On conflict

The map illustrates conflict itself. Any of its five positions can also be projected onto other people.

In everyday life

Irony and self-contradiction always point to whatever a thesis leaves out.

Where there's irony, there's insight.

Free personality test

See the map for your own type.

The free Personality Dynamics Assessment takes about ten minutes and tells you your two core functions. The app shows each one's Shadow Map and Development Pathways.

SeerExplorerStalwartTacticianSageCommanderLoverCaregiver